Retrieving Medical Records for Litigation

Medical records are essential to litigation success in personal injury, malpractice, disability, and workers’ compensation cases. They serve as the foundation for evidence, help validate claims, and often determine case direction. But getting complete, timely, and legally admissible records isn't always simple.

This guide outlines a steadfast approach to medical record retrieval, helping legal professionals avoid delays, reduce risk, and stay in control of the process.

The Strategic Importance of Medical Records in Litigation

Medical records are more than just paperwork—they are core to case-building. They link incidents to injuries, confirm treatments, and document how a client’s condition changed over time. Strong record sets enable legal teams to argue from a position of clarity and confidence.

Key roles these records play include:

Establishing causation and linking it to incidents
Supporting or disputing the severity and timeline of injury
Documenting treatment costs, duration, and medical opinions
Reinforcing or challenging witness statements

Complete, well-organized medical files help attorneys develop effective case strategies, avoid being caught off guard, and prepare for expert testimony or insurance negotiations. Missing or incomplete records, on the other hand, leave room for doubt—something no litigator can afford.

Current Challenges Facing Legal Teams

Despite their importance, medical records can be difficult to retrieve. Legal professionals report mounting difficulties in getting records on time and in the right format—especially when working across multiple providers and platforms.

Some of the most common challenges include:

Fragmented healthcare systems, where records are stored in different facilities with varying policies
Inconsistent portal processes, each with its own access rules, timelines, and submission formats
Tight deadlines, where even minor delays can result in missed discovery or trial milestones

Provider portal fragmentation has grown significantly in recent years. Many healthcare organizations now require patients or requestors to use their specific online portal—each with unique forms, ID verification steps, and limitations on third-party access. This adds complexity, especially for firms managing hundreds of record requests.

The result? Attorneys risk working from partial information, scrambling before deadlines, or facing HIPAA-related pushback for incorrect submissions.

Step 1: Identify the Records You Need

Before submitting a request, clarify exactly which records your case requires. Overbroad submissions can lead to delays or denials. If it’s too narrow, you may miss critical documentation.

Common Record Types and Supporting Tools

Depending on the matter type, legal teams may need:

Personal Injury Cases: ER reports, hospital records, surgical notes, therapy logs, imaging scans, prescriptions, billing statements, and medical histories.
Workers’ Compensation Cases: Employment records, billing analyses, and case summaries tied to the incident.
Disability or Malpractice Cases: Physician evaluations, diagnostic tests, specialist reports, and pre-incident care documentation

Lexitas also offers Record Insights®, a specialized service that helps legal teams organize and analyze records more effectively. For firms handling complex cases, a well-prepared medical chronology can be a powerful tool for identifying treatment gaps, sequencing events, and preparing for expert review.

Knowing exactly what records you need—and how to structure your request strategically—helps ensure compliance, avoid delays, and support your overall litigation strategy.

Relevance Matters

Request only what you need to support your case. Review timelines, identify any treatment gaps, and make sure you account for:

Pre-existing conditions vs. new complaints
Future medical costs
Mental health impacts, where relevant

Look for documentation that separates pre-accident conditions from current ones. That could include a provider noting a “worsening” of symptoms, or comparing old scans to new ones.

Legal Scope and Privacy Limits

Medical record requests must be precise. Under HIPAA, only the “minimum necessary” information should be disclosed for litigation. Broad or poorly defined requests are more likely to be denied, and can raise compliance concerns.

Always align your requests with what is directly relevant to the case, and confirm they meet both legal and provider-specific requirements before submission.

Step 2: Obtain Proper Authorization or Legal Basis

Even with a strong case and clear record targets, you still need legal access. HIPAA and other privacy laws outline how, when, and to whom medical records can be disclosed.

Getting HIPAA-Compliant Authorization

Start with a signed HIPAA release. Any missing or incorrect fields can result in outright denial. Make sure the form includes:

The patient’s full name, DOB, and contact details
What records are being requested and for what purpose
An expiration date
Signatures and witness verification where needed

Using Subpoenas and Court Orders

If a patient won’t authorize access, you can still obtain records via:

Court orders signed by judges or administrative tribunals
Subpoenas (deposition, witness, or duces tecum) properly issued and served

Note: Some providers will only comply with a subpoena if it includes a judge’s signature. Confirm requirements with the facility before serving.

Special Scenarios: Minors and Incapacitated Clients

Include documentation proving legal authority with your request. When a patient can’t provide authorization:

A parent or legal guardian must sign for minors
A court-appointed decision-maker or executor may be needed for incapacitated or deceased individuals

Step 3: Navigate Provider and Facility Requirements

Once you have legal access, the next step is understanding and meeting each provider’s specific process.

Processing Timelines

Most providers aim to fulfill requests within 30 to 45 days, follow up consistently, and document all outreach. Real-world timelines vary:

Hospitals often take 10–15 business days,
Clinics and private practices may be faster but less consistent
Expedited processing may be available for urgent cases

Required Documentation

Always confirm what each provider requires. Avoid editing signed forms, and if changes are needed, submit a new form. At a minimum, requestors should prepare:

A valid, dated authorization form with matching patient info
The requestor’s contact info and relation to the case
A description of the records requested and their intended use

Why Requests Get Denied

Top reasons include:

Incorrect or missing patient information
Unclear record scope
Expired or altered authorization forms
Failure to meet provider-specific submission protocols (e.g., portals, fax, mail)

Step 4: Manage Timelines Strategically

Record delays can cost you. They affect case prep, expert review, settlement leverage, and client trust. Managing timelines is about more than tracking dates—it’s about building buffer time into your strategy.

Know the Legal Deadlines

Plan record requests early, especially if expert testimony or third-party review is involved.

Under HIPAA, providers typically have 30 days to respond to medical record requests. Some states have elongated impose shorter timelines or additional requirements, so it’s important to confirm any jurisdiction-specific rules early in the process.

When expert review or third-party analysis is required, initiate requests as soon as possible to stay on track.

Early Retrieval = Better Strategy

Make retrieval a standard part of intake or discovery prep, not a last-minute task. Getting records early lets your team:

Develop timelines and causation arguments sooner
Identify gaps, red flags, or contradictions
Avoid costly rush reviews or continuances

Step 5: Ensure Chain of Custody and Compliance

Records are only useful if they’re admissible and secure. Mishandling medical records can lead to compliance issues, evidence challenges, or regulatory penalties.

Admissibility Requirements

Check with your jurisdiction for any pre-admission notice requirements. To use medical records in court, ensure:

They are relevant and authenticated
Their collection method complies with court and privacy rules
Chain of custody is clear and complete

Chain of Custody: Digital vs. Physical

Maintain logs of who accessed the records and when.

Digital Records must be transmitted securely (encrypted email or secure portals)
Physical Records should be logged, stored securely, and not altered

Stay HIPAA-Compliant

HIPAA violations can result in steep fines and reputational damage. To maintain HIPAA compliance for law firms:

Limit access to only necessary individuals
Use secure storage and transmission tools
Avoid printing or emailing PHI unless encrypted

Why Partner with a Record Retrieval Service

Trusted medical records retrieval companies reduce admin strain, lower risk, and speed up access. They know the systems, forms, and timelines. Most importantly, they help your team stay focused on legal work, not chasing paperwork.

Key Benefits

Faster turnaround times with fewer rejections
Better accuracy and organization
Scalable support for growing caseloads

These services also provide digital formatting, chronology tools, and cloud access—making review faster and easier.

Jurisdictional Expertise Adds Value

Local laws matter. Services familiar with state, provincial, and provider-specific policies can prevent unnecessary delays and compliance mistakes.

Make Records Work for You, Not Against You

Record retrieval shouldn't be an afterthought. When done early, efficiently, and correctly, it improves case strategy, helps secure better outcomes, and protects your clients.

Whether you're handling complex litigation or a straightforward personal injury case, partnering with Lexitas for medical record retrieval ensures you get the records you need—organized, compliant, and on time.

Stay ahead of the deadline. Stay focused on what matters most.

Ready to streamline your medical record retrieval process?

Lexitas offers secure, reliable, and scalable solutions tailored to litigation support. From HIPAA-compliant access to fast turnaround times, our team helps you get the records you need—organized, on time, and done right.

Explore Lexitas Record Retrieval

Frequently Asked Questions About Medical Record Retrieval

How long do providers have to respond to medical record requests under HIPAA?

Under HIPAA, healthcare providers typically have up to 30 days to respond to a valid medical record request, though this does not mean you will get the record back in that time. Some states may offer elongated timelinesrequire shorter response times, so it’s important to verify local statutes when planning record retrieval timelines.

What happens if a medical records request is denied?

Denials most often result from incomplete or incorrect forms, lack of proper authorization, or requests for information that cannot legally be disclosed, such as content that could harm the patient or includes third-party data. Legal teams should review the reason for denial, correct any errors, and resubmit the request promptly. In some cases, the denial may be based on legal or medical grounds related to patient privacy or safety.

Can I request records without patient authorization?

Yes, but only under specific legal conditions. A valid court order or subpoena may allow access without patient consent. However, most providers will require a signed HIPAA-compliant authorization form unless compelled by a court.

What is a medical chronology, and why is it useful?

A medical chronology is a structured timeline of a patient’s healthcare events related to a legal case. It helps legal teams understand the sequence of care, identify relevant details quickly, and prepare for expert review or litigation milestones.

Why use a medical record retrieval service?

Professional record retrieval services reduce delays, improve accuracy, and free up internal resources. They understand provider-specific requirements, help ensure HIPAA compliance, and streamline access to the records needed to support litigation.

Brandy Patrick is the President of the Record Retrieval Division of Lexitas. Ms. Patrick has over 17 years of experience in sales, operations, and mergers & acquisitions. Ms. Patrick is a thought leader in the industry, providing deep knowledge of HIPAA and the complex laws impacting record retrieval. Prior to her current role, Ms. Patrick was President of America First Legal Services, a premium record retrieval company acquired by Lexitas.

Connect:

Related Resources

HIPAA-Compliant Safeguards for Your Record Retrieval Partners

HIPAA-compliance is a complex detail that law firms cannot afford to overlook, especially when working with third parties who handle medical records.

When is the right time to outsource your records retrieval services?

Making the decision to outsource your records collection can be a challenging one. However, there are many benefits to doing so.

Transforming Legal Practices with Outsourcing, Technology, and Automation

The legal landscape is evolving faster than ever. To not only survive but thrive, law firms must rethink traditional approaches and tap into strategies that enhance efficiency, control costs, and scale with ease.